What Are the Biggest Web Design Business Mistakes?

Failure is a part of business. It’s something that drives innovation and experimentation, and for many businesses it’s a good indicator that things are actually going quite well. The biggest businesses of today – the Microsoft, Apple, and Nike types – wouldn’t be where they were without their business failures, some of which have been colossally large.

However, there are two different types of business failure. The first is the type that’s forced to occur – experiments with never-before-seen products and new industries. This type of failure is difficult to prevent, especially when you’re a forward-thinking company with plans to dominate your industry.

The second type of failure is easily preventable. It’s the failure that occurs when you don’t think business decisions through; when you rush into an action without research, and when you follow assumptions blindly with no question of where they might lead. It’s the type of failure that catches thousands of businesses every year.

Unfortunately, a lot of those easily preventable failures occur in the world of web design. Both clients and designers are equally guilty of making poor decisions, strategic errors, and planning screw-ups when they invest in a website. We’ve consulted the best minds in web design – authors of some of the top web design blogs, and leaders of some of the best web design businesses – to get their opinion on just what it is that causes so many web design errors.

Forgetting About Opportunity Cost:

“One of the biggest mistakes that businesses make is that they hire cheaply. If you pay under a couple of thousand dollars for a website, it’s almost a guarantee that it’ll cost you in the long run.” – Jacob Gube, Six Revisions

We’ve all heard disaster stories about offshore designers and inexpensive website quotes. More often than not, clients set out with an ambitious project and a limited budget, aiming to get as much as they can for their money.

Unfortunately, things rarely run according to plan. Not only are clients pushed through hundreds of hoops and a shopping list of inconveniences, but they’re typically left with a final product that’s incompatible with their business goals.

Ultra-cheap designers are often exactly the opposite. It’s not uncommon for clients to end up with a website that costs more to repair than it did to design in the first place. It’s even more common for businesses to end up with a website that’s patently unusable, nothing gained from their payment but an expensive (although not that expensive) lesson in online business sense.

If your business operates extensively online, it’s essential that opportunity cost is factored into any strategic decisions or long-term purchases. An inexpensive website might get you online and visible, but it’s unlikely to help you gain extra customers, clients, and enquiries. Cheap labor tends to provide predictably cheap results, leaving your business out of options and out of pocket when the project’s over.

“You get what you pay for. Don’t waste your money on a halfway decent site, save up for a great one.” – Shane Jeffers, Three Styles

Aiming to Please Everyone:

“I don’t know the secret of success, but the secret of failure is to try to please everybody.” – Bill Cosby

“No matter the industry, no matter the goals, you cannot please everyone. That’s just how it works.” – Jon Phillips, Spyre Studios

Advertisers had a hard time adjusting to the internet. The medium’s dynamics weren’t like those they’d seen on TV and radio – rather than flocking together to the same channels, audiences moved apart and found exactly what it was that they liked.

The advertising era before the internet was dominated by mass marketing efforts and one-size-fits-all messages. There was no individuality, and little customization involved. For all the remarks that advertising “homogenizes” people, the internet has served to prove the exact opposite.

Businesses adapting to online commerce often run into the same problems. Shaped by decades of appealing to a mass audience through TV and print advertising, they create their website to catch everyone’s attention and in the same effort end up hooking no one. The same tools that were once so effective for marketing to everybody have become the exact opposite – blunt instruments that capture a great deal of attention, but end up generating little interest.

An effective website allows your business to market to your target customers with razor-like precision. Instead of adapting the old big business strategy of marketing to everyone, online businesses should give their design team a clear goal – cater to the audience that’s most valuable to them, and leave others to find solutions elsewhere.

Ignoring the Balance of Content:

“The biggest mistake is to create a site with poor content. People visit your site looking for information, if they cannot find it, it’s very frustrating. A good design will help the visitors to find the information, so just a good design won’t work unless there’s quality content.” – Fabio Sasso, Abduzeedo

“Businesses often try to cram as much information into the upper portion of the homepage. Because this is the area that receives the most exposure, there’s a battle for the space that can usually end up resulting in overpopulation of information. The user is then left with choice paralysis as nothing really stands out.” – Chris Spooner, SpoonGraphics

There’s no one law for creating an effective website. The two search giants of the web – Google and Yahoo – made this clear in their own websites. Google takes a minimalist approach to their website, giving visitors access only to the information that’s essential. Yahoo took the other option, giving visitors access to almost everything, with different portions of their website allocated to news, weather, and other services.

There’s no clear rule for what information should go on your website. The only clear rule in web design is for how much information should appear on your website. It’s ultimately a business choice, and like other business decisions it deserves, and occasionally demands, some form of relative testing.

The ten-page sales letter is, quite thankfully, a rarity in web design. Businesses have by and large realized that the internet isn’t the place for direct mail efforts, and have given their websites the most important element for results: balance. Treat your website similarly and you’ll gain more than just the occasional prospect, but a steady flow of customers that know what you’re offering.

Lacking Involvement and Interest:

“I work with small and medium sized businesses and many clients want to just hire someone and not be very involved. Most are responsive when I explain to them the need for planning, but I think a lot of businesses could get better results with their sites if they are more proactive and thorough in the early stages.” – Steven Snell, Vandelay Design and DesignM.ag

It’s tempting to write the internet off as something that ‘those designers’ can handle on their own. It’s even more tempting if your business isn’t actively involved in any online commerce efforts – your website serves only as a platform for generating leads, or as a one-off resource for having prospective customers find your phone number.

Unfortunately, the businesses that do write off the internet tend to reinforce their own impressions through poor results. Without two-way communication and clear planning, it’s unlikely that your website will generate anything more than the occasional phone call. Designers aren’t always in tune with your business, and almost always appreciate extra information and direction.

Just like the best advertisements are a blend of business and creativity, the best websites are a collaborative effort between designers and business owners. While it’s tempting to look at your website as a one-off task and slight annoyance, it’s better to look at it through a different lens. Think of the opportunity that a business website provides, and allow enough input to capitalize on it.

Tagged In

About the Author

Mathew Carpenter is an 18-year-old business owner and entrepreneur from Sydney, Australia. Mathew is the owner of AddToDesign, a website which provides value added design buzz, along with Design-Newz, the premier source for aggregated design news. Follow Mathew on Twitter: @matcarpenter.

Share

  • RSS
  • email
  • Add to favorites
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr

There are 13 comments on this article. Want to leave one?

  1. Shane Jeffers

    March 26, 2010 at 12:01 am

    Thanks again Mat for this opportunity. This is a fantastic article that includes some input from talented Designers/Developers it’s an honor to be in the same conversation with them! It’s so true what Jacob said “Hiring Cheaply” is the biggest mistake you can make.

    I’ve come up with a little formula:

    Money + Time = Success

    The more of the first two you put into your business the more of third one (success) you will have. Unfortunately when it comes to a website so many entrepreneurs take the cheap route and end up having to refresh the site every year or so.

    Great article Mat.

  2. Outsourcing

    March 26, 2010 at 6:49 am

    Your blog is so informative … keep up the good work!!!!

  3. Business Presentation

    March 26, 2010 at 8:24 am

    Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your post to my blog?

  4. Virgilio Astudillo

    March 26, 2010 at 9:03 am

    Hi, i must say fantastic website you have, i stumbled across it in Google. Does you get much traffic? If you wantto swap the links with us please let me know.

  5. Love Lyrics

    March 26, 2010 at 11:29 am

    Thanks for a awesome post and interesting comments. I found this post while looking for some lyrics. Thanks for sharing this story.

  6. Edmonton zip

    March 26, 2010 at 5:18 pm

    When was this published? I’ve been looking all around for weeks for decent info. Great article, I’ve bookmarked the site.

  7. play games

    March 26, 2010 at 5:50 pm

    I’m going to save this as inspiration and send visitors from my lens. I’ve just put up some new ideas too, so I’ll include a hypelink to your post (if OK) on my site?

  8. Van Macia

    March 27, 2010 at 12:50 am

    Much like normal you’ve offered some good info. Been a lurker on the website for a while and wanted to say thanks to you for finding the time to create it.

  9. Mathew Carpenter

    March 27, 2010 at 2:35 am

    Thanks for all the positive comments!

    @Shane – your formula is absolutely correct! Is it essential that if you want to make a project a success, you must put the time and effort into it.

  10. Johnny Imboden

    March 27, 2010 at 12:43 pm

    This blog is great. How did you come up witht he idea? 8 2 9

  11. Alice Dagley

    March 31, 2010 at 4:07 am

    Thank you for the article. In spite of the fact that your list is tooooooo short, I fully agree with you. The first point is the most important. Now we have to face a very burning problem – deflation in freelance market. Freelance market increases every year. And supply is much higher than demand. Nowadays freelancers from Third World countries underprice services attempting to earn money. Some years ago it was possible to attract clients with high-quality services vs low prices. And clients made a choice between “expensive” cool designs and cheap poor “drawings”. However it’s high time to admit that price doesn’t depend on quality any longer. And often freelancers offer high quality design at a low price. They reduce their quotes to pick up a client and don’t foresee that they lose their profits and don’t let the others to benefit.

  12. Stephen Leung

    April 4, 2010 at 1:05 pm

    Man, thanks a bunch. Very informative post. It really taught me a lot about Online Design Business.

  13. masonic lodge

    April 29, 2010 at 7:35 am

    Your article was very attention grabbing and was just what I was seeking for.

Leave a Reply